St. Elmo Steakhouse in Indianapolis is a James Beard award-winning restaurant celebrated for its delicious steaks, but more widely known for its extremely spicy Shrimp Cocktail. It was once deemed the “spiciest food in the world” by Travel Channel writer Allison Stein Wellner. Insider producer Jake Gabbard traveled to Indianapolis, got advice from competitive eater Joey Chestnut, tried this fabled appetizer, and ultimately decided if it was Worth The Drive.
