ADNAN OKTAR: Mawlana addresses himself as "the holy of holies Mawlana, his Excellency Mawlana, Hazrat Mawlana." And he calls our Prophet (saas) 'Mustafa.' Look at his statement; "When Al-Mustafa was beset with the woe of separation, when he would feel distressed, he would attempt to throw himself from the mountain." Look at how he speaks about the Prophet (saas). "When he feels distressed." Who are you to use such a language when you speak about the Prophet (saas)? He addresses the Prophet (saas) with his name, ‘Mustafa,’ as if they are friends. "He would only calm down and desist from committing suicide when Gabriel would told him 'Do not do this; many realms are ordained to you by God's commandment 'Be!'” Look, what he implies is that the Prophet Muhammad (saas) stops not for the sake of God, but for the sake of authority and property. In other words, he says that our Prophet (saas) would not calm down out of love and fear of God. Do you see? It is a bizarre statement. He says "He would only calm down when Gabriel offers him property and desist from committing suicide. But when the woe of separation returned to him, when troubles overwhelmed him, he would again want to throw himself from a mountain" presenting our Prophet (saas) as a person with suicidal tendencies (surely our Prophet (saas) is beyond such claims). And he presents himself as sound of mind. "Such a person was Mustafa" he says -we hold our Prophet (saas) above such thoughts. Furthermore, Mawlana addresses the Prophet (saas) as if he is his friend. "He would only calm down when he was offered property and desist from committing suicide" he says. Not out of his fear and love of God. (Masnavi, page 294.)
BÜLENT SEZGİN: "When Al-Mustafa was beset with the woe of separation, when he would feel distressed, he would attempt to throw himself from the mountain." "He would only calm down and back down when Gabriel would tell him 'Do not do this; many realms are ordained to you by God's commandment 'Be!' But when the woe of separation returned to him, when he would get down from troubles, he would again want to throw himself from a mountain" (surely our Prophet (saas) is beyond such claims).
ADNAN OKTAR: He is praising himself while speaking ill of the Messenger of God (saas).
http://en.a9.com.tr/watch/230885/Adnan-Oktarin-Sohbetlerinden-Secme-Bolumler/In-Masnavi-Mawlana-uses-profane-language-about-our-Prophet-(saas)
A9 uygulama mobil linkler :
A9 TV iphone : http://itunes.apple.com/tr/app/a9-tv/id432879700
A9 Radyo iphone : https://itunes.apple.com/tr/app/a9-tv-radio/id929302730
A9 TV Android : https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.chelik.client.a9tv
A9 Radyo Android: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.chelik.clients.a9radyo
