This is the story all about how a pitcher named Will Smith got thrown out. The Milwaukee Brewers reliever came into the seventh inning of what was then a 2-1 ball game against the Atlanta Braves. He'd throw four pitches to one batter before Braves manager Fredi Gonzalez pointed out to the umps what was so painfully obvious to anyone watching at home: Will Smith had a shiny, foreign substance on his forearm.